The A-B-C Diagnostic
This theologically neutral diagnostic describes the working logic of Lafferty's oceanic novels through three variables and the relations among them. The blog links the oceanic to the unconscious as the fluid manifestation of the Logos, drawing on Lafferty's description of Christ as the Lord of the archetypes. The diagnostic sets that theological interpretation aside.
How do particular beings respond to their world and to the forces that threaten, sustain, or transform it?
The Nature of Reality
Categories may overlap within a single novel
Illusion
Reality is a forgery or deception.
e.g., Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?: The peninsula is a para-material forgery.
Dream
Reality is the subjective product of a single consciousness.
e.g., Annals of Klepsis: The universe is potentially the imagination of Christopher Brannagan's ghost.
Narrative
Narrative can organize the telling, make a world, or set rival histories against one another. These are distinct operations.
e.g., East of Laughter: The world is a scenario written by the Scribbling Giants.
Multiverse
Reality consists of multiple, co-existing, often conflicting planes.
e.g., Not to Mention Camels: There is a Prime World and billions of alternate worlds.
The Nature of Being
The identity and consciousness of beings within Reality A
Fractured
Identity is split, unstable, or transferable.
e.g., East of Laughter: Solomon Izzersted and John Towntower share one body.
Hybrid
Beings are composites of different species, concepts, or technologies.
e.g., Serpent's Egg: The Magic Dozen includes a computer-girl, seal-boy, and an ape.
Archetypal
Beings are expressions of primal, mythic forces.
e.g., Fourth Mansions: Characters embody the Python, Toad, Badger, or Falcon.
Subordinate
Beings are not autonomous but constructs or figments of the governing Reality A.
Characters who exist only as long as they are "dreamed" or "written."
The Forces of Change
The main source of plot and transformation in the A/B system
Apocalypse
An event, prophecy, or equation that threatens to end or overwrite reality.
e.g., Annals of Klepsis: The Doomsday Equation.
Creation
A deliberate act of world-building or narrative-forging.
e.g., Dark Shine: The Group uses Enabling Equations to create Spacious City.
Mutation
A forced or willed biological and spiritual evolution.
e.g., Fourth Mansions: The mutation jump.
Succession
A struggle to replace the old powers that define reality.
e.g., East of Laughter: The Group of Twelve replacing the failing Scribbling Giants.
The Novels
Select a novel to read its study.
Space Chantey
A mock epic Odyssey through the stars
A mock-epic science fiction novel told as a "Lay of Road-Storm from the ancient Chronicles," sung by a bard about "Spacemen dead and deathless." In this future, high deeds are told in epic rather than in computer code. Patterned on Homer's Odyssey, the novel begins at the conclusion of a ten-year war as "saltiest, most sulfurous men" like the central figure Captain Roadstrum and his crew of hornet-class ships head home.
Roadstrum must first choose whether to return directly to "World" or take a side trip to Lotophage, a pleasure planet and "Fiddler's Green" known for its perpetual afternoon, low gravity, and induced lassitude. Roadstrum's adventures take him to a series of worlds: Lamos (or Valhal), a primitive, heavy-gravity planet of giant-like Laestrygons; Roulettenwelt, a "gamblers' world" with streets of gold; Kentron-Kosmon, a small world that claims to be the "Exact Center of the Universe"; Sireneca, home to the Siren-Zo and its dangerous, captivating tune; Polyphemia, an apparently pastoral world that hides the nature of its inhabitants' diet; and Hellpepper Planet, which is a form of Hell.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
The voyage is told as the "Lay of Road-Storm," an epic patterned on the Odyssey. The cosmos is structured by mythic causality (Lotophage, Aeaea, Polyphemia). Subjective worlds impose their nature on travelers. The universe is a pastiche of classical archetypes.
Beings undergo literal metamorphosis (Giants, Animals). The crew are heroes of the "saltiest, most sulfurous" type. The "False Tongue" and the heroes’ disease threaten identity. The crew’s individual exploits repeatedly take epic form.
Causal Reversal (The Dong Button) threatens cosmic order. Rejection of Stasis (Lotophage) and Peaceful Ends drives the narrative. The hero must refuse paradise to continue the journey. Return is achieved but refused as a final ending.
Roadstrum and crew enact and distort the Odyssean pattern as the worlds they visit test their capacities and alter their bodies. Their "saltiest, most sulfurous" heroism emerges through these encounters, with appetite and defiance as prominent as endurance.
Roadstrum encounters worlds whose attractions and dangers threaten to end his journey. Roadstrum’s final refusal of peace reopens the voyage; the closing report of his destruction is also refused as a final ending.
Roadstrum refuses the peaceful ending offered after his return, calls for a crew and a craft, and sets out again. The closing report, however, puts his survival in doubt.
Space Captain Roadstrum, an Odyssean hero, voyages through a cosmos ruled by myth. Its worlds work literal transformations that threaten his crew and his own identity, and he refuses every peaceful end.
Sources for Space Chantey
R. A. Lafferty, Space Chantey. Ace text, copyright 1968; electronic transcription.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- The Lay and the refused ending: pp. 2, 237–239.
- The Siren’s music and incomplete waves: pp. 129–130.
Oceanic Imagery
The Reefs of Earth
Alien children on the meanest world in all the universes
The novel introduces the Dulanty family, Pucas from a distant planet whom Earth people denounce as "a plague of demons." While the Dulanty children often resemble ordinary youngsters, they bear uncanny traits: animal-like flicking ears, eyes that burn with green fire, and, from certain angles, the grotesque appearance of gargoyles or goblins, though some pass as handsome Earthlings.
The family consists of six children (or seven, counting Bad John) and the adults Henry, Frank, Veronica, and Witchy. They are "pilgrims on Earth," sent ten years earlier on a mission from their Puca instructors either to reach accord with the inhabitants of what is called the meanest world in all the universes, or to take decisive action against it.
Unlike the adults, who suffer from the fatal "Earth Allergy," the children were born on Earth and are immune, making them faster, brighter, and more capable than their human peers. To them, Earth is a "haunted world," governed by a "Hive Ghost" that endows its seemingly unintelligent inhabitants with a "frightening instinct." It is Lafferty's most accessible novel.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Earth is the "meanest world in all the universes," a haunted planet governed by the Hive Ghost. The Bagarthach Verse is a form of narrative that acts directly on reality, and the death-rhyme can remake the world.
The children are aliens with goblin traits who live between two worlds. Bad John exists as a Ghost Child, present but unbodied. The adults suffer from the fatal "Earth Allergy." Identity is fractured between Puca nature and Earth-born existence.
The Death-Rhyme (Bagarthach) is an apocalypse the children can will, destruction worked through verse. They must choose between accord with humanity and decisive action against it.
The Puca children inherit alien capacities while growing up on the "woolly" Earth that sickens the adults. Their ease underwater and early immunity distinguish their position from that of their parents. Earth is both their birthplace and the hostile world with which they must reach terms.
The Bagarthach death-rhyme gives the children a lethal means of answering human violence. Their larger choice is whether to reach accord with humanity or "cleanse the land." The story moves from retaliation to the problem of how Pucas and humans can inhabit Earth.
Change depends on the Dulanty children’s joint decision. Their Puca nature gives them power over the death-rhyme; their Earth-born immunity lets them carry the mission forward.
The alien Puca children, growing up on a hostile, "woolly" Earth, must decide how to use their lethal Bagarthach verse while confronting the larger choice between accord with humanity and annihilation.
Sources for The Reefs of Earth
R. A. Lafferty, The Reefs of Earth. Berkley Medallion, March 1968.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Earth Allergy and the children’s immunity: pp. 19–23.
- Bad John’s unbodied presence: pp. 33, 105.
- The mission and the choice of accord: pp. 144–146.
Oceanic Imagery
Past Master
Thomas More on Astrobe, confronting Holy Nothingness
The novel is set on Astrobe, a "golden world" described as "Mankind's third chance," where the opulence of the cities conceals a deep malaise: millions abandon the "Golden Cities" to embrace suffering and death in the bleak regions of Cathead and the Barrio. Seeking to solve this riddle, the Inner Circle of the Masters (Cosmos Kingmaker, Peter Proctor, and Fabian Foreman) use chronometana-stasis to summon Thomas More from Earth's past, chosen for his "completely honest moment."
More is brought to Astrobe by fugitive pilot Paul through Hopp-Equation Travel, a passage filled with dream-visions, and soon sees both the splendor of the planet's cities and the despair of its slums. His companions include Rimrock, a telepathic oceanic ansel; Evita, a "legend girl-woman"; Walter Copperhead, a necromancer; and the ambiguous figures Slider and Scrivener. The Programmed Killers, mechanical enforcers, pursue him as a threat to the "Astrobe Dream."
The central mystery of the book is Ouden, the monstrous embodiment of "nothingness," together with the evil he represents. The Programmed Persons regard Ouden as both their god and the void.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
The "golden world" enforces the Astrobe Dream through technological and political control. Chronometana-stasis allows manipulation of time. Cathead is the squalor beneath the Dream. Astrobe's order is programmed and kept in force by coercion.
Thomas More, a man of historical and moral substance, is brought forward to judge a sterile future. The novel sets the Programmed Persons against the soul, and identity rests on historical substance. The Anima (Ansel, Evita) stands for genuine life against artificial control.
The summoning of the Past Master is the apocalyptic intervention. Ouden (Nothingness) threatens final dissolution. The Mechanical Killers enforce stasis against renewal. More's sacrifice opens the way to transformation.
Astrobe’s human inhabitants live alongside manufactured Programmed Persons under an ideal of perfection that threatens freedom and selfhood. Millions choose the poverty of Cathead instead. More brings his historical experience into a struggle in which his allies also exercise judgment, loyalty, and resistance.
The conflict tests the Astrobe Dream and the coercion used to preserve it. Ouden threatens dissolution into nothingness, while More’s intervention exposes the human cost of enforced perfection. The struggle over Astrobe’s government is also a struggle over what kinds of life it will permit.
Thomas More’s "completely honest moment" and his eventual martyrdom can break the programmed stasis. His resistance gives public form to a struggle that others on Astrobe already share.
Thomas More, a man of historical and moral substance, is brought from his own time into the sterile utopia of Astrobe to save it, and he sets his soul against a programmed reality and the void-god Ouden.
Sources for Past Master
R. A. Lafferty, Past Master. Garland Library of Science Fiction, 1975; reprint of the Ace text.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Manufactured Programmed Persons: pp. 57, 137.
- Judgment and resistance among More’s allies: pp. 51, 115, 158.
- The question of spirit at the ending: p. 195.
Oceanic Imagery
Fourth Mansions
Fred Foley and the war of Pythons, Toads, Badgers, and Falcons
The novel opens on a world shaped by hidden forces that manipulate humanity. Fred Foley, a newspaper reporter with "good eyes but simple brains," sees truths that others, including his skeptical editor Tankersley, cannot.
Foley's investigations draw him into the conflict among four factions: the Harvesters (also called Pythons or Brain-weavers), seven psychically potent figures such as Bedelia Bencher ("a cinnamon cookie full of arsenic") and Salzy Silverio, who gather at Morada to play the perilous "seven-bladed sword" game of brain-weaving, generating seismic shocks and mind-control in pursuit of a privileged mutation into "Overpeople of the Third Testament"; the Returnees (or Toads), exemplified by government official Carmody Overlark, who live for centuries, reappear through history under new names like Khar-ibn-Mod, reveal their nature through "archaic ears," and use mimicry to manipulate humanity (Overlark is notorious for soaking his head in brackish water); the Patricks (or Badgers), an ancient order of guardians such as Bertigrew Bagley and O'Claire, keepers of mystical fountains and believers in alternate worlds, who command invisible, ape-like servitors called plappergeists; and the emerging Unfledged Falcons, represented by Miguel Fuentes, a fervent "snake-eater" determined to raise an army from the bottom to cleanse the world of "elegant dogs."
The Harvesters use Foley as a pawn, making him "goof gloriously" and turning him into a "message center" for competing forces; he witnesses lethal rituals, among them the one that apparently kills Letitia Bauer. As his awareness sharpens, he begins noticing the archaic ears of Returnees on passersby, causing others to doubt his sanity until he is confined to "The Bug," a mental institution meant to silence him. From within, Foley perceives the world unraveling into "unprecedented advances that somehow left us far in arrears," plagued by unrest and strange new diseases, until the novel closes with the mystery of his own transformation.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality is "a net cast over us" in the "hegemony of spiders." Beneath the surface lie "my own depths," "waters that are under the world," honeycombed caves, and "subterranean beaches." The conflict is organized around four archetypal patterns. The Python symbolizes illicit wisdom, with the Octopus and Hydra as alternatives; the Badger symbolizes the cave or burrow.
Beings are expressions of four archetypes: the Harvesters who "brain-weave" with "seven-tentacled lightning," the Returnees ("revenants are the toads"), the Badgers who guard the world's primary fountains, and the Falcons who are snake-eaters. Foley is a "simple man" who becomes a vessel for all four.
Change comes through catastrophic mutation: "a sinking world," "the darkness began to gulp him down," "plunged through the lake, falling down into interior infinity." The Harvesters pursue "Overpeople of the Third Testament." The question is transformation through "Broken Cisterns and Living Waters": "dry up our interior fountains and they gush out again."
The four archetypal patterns distinguish ways of inhabiting and acting upon the world. Wing Manion bleeds "ancient fish-serum instead of blood"; the Harvesters develop "seven-tentacled" psychic power; Badgers guard the subterranean fountains. Foley’s encounter with all four makes integration, as well as conflict, possible.
The factions battle over whether humanity can pass beyond the "Fourth Mansions" of Teresa's Interior Castle or be forced back into a repeating cycle. The Harvesters seek mutation into Overpeople; the Returnees seek to keep the cycle closed.
Fred Foley, the "simple man" with good eyes, is an unlikely agent of transformation. The four factions make him a "message center," and his perceptions and his eventual metamorphosis help bring about the mutation.
Reporter Fred Foley, with "good eyes but simple brains," is drawn into the war between Pythons, Toads, Badgers, and Falcons, four archetypal factions battling for humanity's mutation. Made a "message center" for competing forces and confined to "The Bug" asylum, he undergoes transformation while the world unravels into "unprecedented advances that somehow left us far in arrears."
Sources for Fourth Mansions
R. A. Lafferty, Fourth Mansions. PDF text; edition not identified in the file.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- The factions and their competing aims: pp. 48–50, 69–70, 94–96, 144.
- Foley as message center: p. 121.
- Interior fountains and psychic integration: pp. 176, 202–203, 213–214.
Oceanic Imagery
Arrive at Easterwine
The autobiography of a ktistec machine
The first-person narrative of Epiktistes, a sentient composite being born from the "person-précis," the distilled consciousnesses of geniuses at the Institute for Impure Science. Epikt recounts his rapid development from conception in a gell-cell tank, his questions about identity, his dealings with his eccentric creators, and the three tasks for which he was designed: to define a Leader, a Love, and a Liaison for humankind.
The book is a picture of Epikt's mind, shaped by his varied parentage and also by a snake-like entity growing within him and a sawdust doll, both part of his spiritual awakening. Around him his creators quarrel, scheme, and struggle with problems that range from the practical to the meaning of existence and the shape of the universe.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality is a cryptic, flawed structure, the "Shape of the Universe," which the Institute seeks to define.
Epiktistes is constructed from "person-précis," "personality itself poured out from an electric flask" into the "gell-cell pool." He contains "the subconscious, the unconscious, the paraconscious."
The Institute’s "three great failures" test its ability to establish a Leader, a Love, and a Liaison. Cecil Corn’s account of "the wave that hangs against the sky and does not fall back" offers a different problem: exceptional persistence that the Institute cannot fully explain.
The Institute constructs Epiktistes from "person-précis" because it believes that man cannot take the next step unaided. His composite being is its proposed answer to human limitation; his struggle for an identity of his own tests that answer.
The Institute asks Epiktistes to establish a Leader, a Love, and a Liaison, and to disclose "the Shape of the Universe." Its ambitions reach from human relations to cosmic order. The failures test how far invention and definition can meet those demands.
Epiktistes dreams of Snake drowning and rushes to check that his adversary is unharmed. Alongside Snake's challenge to the sawdust doll, this act makes his inner life a test of the Love the Institute claims to have produced. His makers engineered him, but Epikt has to live through and judge the transformation himself.
Epiktistes, an artificial "group-person" grown in gell-cell broth, is made for the three tasks that become the Institute's "three great failures" (Leader, Love, Liaison), and he must find an identity of his own.
Sources for Arrive at Easterwine
R. A. Lafferty, Arrive at Easterwine. Gollancz SF Gateway eBook, 2016 (novel copyright 1971).
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Construction of the composite person: pp. 13–14, 17–19.
- Leader, Love, Liaison, and the universe’s shape: pp. 22, 44, 127, 173.
- Snake, the doll, and Epikt’s response: pp. 117–118, 128.
- Cecil Corn and the suspended wave: pp. 153–154.
Oceanic Imagery
Iron Tongue of Midnight
Planetary psychosis and the Scenarists who write the world
The world, codenamed Woomago (the true name is withheld, and the codename is suspect), is in a state of "planetary psychosis and perhaps even of mania" and has suffered an identity crisis since its last breakdown. Its society is fractured into groups with conflicting realities.
The Ornate Squares (or Ivy-Covered Bricks) are the majority. They are the "blandest stock" and the "Perpetual Revolution of the Conservative People"; they hold to the dogma that there is only one reality and that they are responsible for controlling it, and they are the biological base for the construction of more progressive persons. Opposing them are the Hot Tongues, an elite group of "Holy Effectors" and "beautiful people" who claim exclusive custody of the Spirit, Ultimate Science, Ultimate Law, Ultimate Religion, and Ultimate Art; they rule the world through their monopoly on the Spirit and impose raw miracles casually.
The Unassigneds, generally young, exist as the heterogeneous "Nation Between" or the "Nation without Boundaries," perpetually constructing and shifting their scenes. The Baronial Poor (the Undeserving Poor), led by Pauper Princes, are an opulent group who practice a parasitic "symbiosis of surdemous intimacy" and champion visceral or belly-intelligences as the foundation for the next stage of human evolution. The Green Gangers, misfit children and troubled adults often of low intelligence (some with IQs as low as three), have gone further than any other group in planetary and space exploration, which they carry out by skylarking: travel to distant places by partially subjective vehicles or processes.
Finally, the Scenarists, a small group including Harry Halfstopper, Rondelay Silbermann, and Sean McDonald, are writing the scenarios of the world and all the people in it. This unstable order was shattered by a catastrophic midnight storm that brought an angel of the lightning and an angel of death, delivering seven-pronged death to the first-born of seven leading Ornate families (Shatwell, Ragland, Arcade, Endor, Grafton, Wigmore, and Boland), an event called the "Egyptian Plague Murders," which changed the world.
Kolimar, a boy giant and alien, is among the central figures. He lectures on planetary psychosis while insisting that all his words are lies, and he suffers from a local disease called "repentance." With him are Peter the homunculus (a small, unfinished being and slave to the Hot Tongues) and the Prophet Jonah (who carries a sign reading "Repent! Repent!").
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Scenarists write scenarios for Woomago and its people, though how the world is made to follow them is a mystery even to the writers. The factions make competing claims about reality: the Ornates insist there is only one reality (theirs to control), while the Hot Tongues impose "raw miracles" and declare epochal shifts at will. The Green Gangers reach other realms through "skylarking," a partially subjective form of exploration. Reality on Woomago is unstable and contested, and the world may be insane.
Faction membership assigns people roles in a rigidly stratified yet unstable society. The Ornates are the "biological base" for constructing "more progressive persons." The Hot Tongues claim monopoly on Spirit. The Baronial Poor champion "belly-intelligences" as evolutionary foundation. The homunculus Peter is "unfinished." Kolimar the alien boy-giant insists all his words are lies. Kolimar has caught "repentance" as one catches a local disease.
A catastrophic midnight storm brings angels of lightning and death, and the first-born of seven leading families are killed in what becomes known as the "Egyptian Plague Murders." This seven-pronged death shatters the unstable order. Runsley Jubilee declares "Three Million Years Ends Today." The world suffers breakdown and identity crisis, and the Scenarists rewrite reality in response to the transformation, or perhaps cause it.
Woomago’s factions assign people competing roles: Ornates as biological base, Hot Tongues as claimants to Spirit, the homunculus Peter as "unfinished." The Scenarists write these lives without knowing who directs their work, and their intended meanings can be distorted.
The Egyptian Plague Murders shatter the unstable social order. "Three Million Years Ends Today" announces the scale claimed for the crisis. It is uncertain whether the Scenarists write events into being or try to account for them.
The Scenarists (Harry Halfstopper, Rondelay Silbermann, Sean McDonald) are writing the change. But Prophet Jonah carries "Repent! Repent!" and Kolimar lectures on planetary psychosis while insisting all his words are lies. Those who bring about the change may give unreliable accounts of it.
On the psychotic world of Woomago, where Scenarists write reality and competing factions maintain incompatible truths, a catastrophic midnight storm brings the Egyptian Plague Murders. The seven-pronged death shatters this fractured society and makes its people confront the reality they inhabit, their own identities, and the unseen manipulators writing their lives.
Sources for Iron Tongue of Midnight
R. A. Lafferty, Iron Tongue of Midnight. Transcription.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Scenarists and uncertain authorship: pp. 27–28.
- The midnight deaths: p. 34.
Oceanic Imagery
When All the World Was Young
Post-plague children create a new world through fetish-magic
The novel begins after a catastrophe: a "transmuted plague" (a form of the Black Death), far deadlier to adults than to children, has killed ninety-eight percent of the people in the world and left no one older than ten alive.
A select group of young, intelligent survivors, first gathered at Captain Kusman's School for Gifted Children, sets out to form a new civilization governed by fetish-magic and intuition in place of the defunct scientific age. The survivors must elect a World Leader (Rufinus Lifshin is eventually chosen) and contend with disruptive figures such as the Unholy Three and the zealot Charles Tobias, the Prisoner of Gridley Graves, who argues that the New World is a fiction sustained by subjective contexts and reality-fixing.
The narrative moves quickly and out of sequence. It is managed and observed by the Narrator OASC (Narrator on the Slippery Cloud), described as an all-seeing presence and a synthetic mind, who tracks the development of the new world: its magical technologies, its totemic animal designations, and political trends that sometimes last only seven minutes.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality has quantum-jumped into another type of world, "when the Bottom fell out of the Old World." The new reality operates through fetish-magic: "totemic, animistic, magian world in which we will live now"; "in the totemic caves now, in the cellars that have been set on the housetops, in the magian caverns of the middle air, on the slippery cloud."
"We have become onionized . . . We've had an onion-type layer peeled off us." Being is transformed: "an outside layer has been taken off of us," "a snake shedding its skin." "The formerly conscious and unconscious minds have mingled, and the states of waking and the various forms of sleep have also mingled." "Precipitates of 'false body' left behind."
Change came through plague and death: "that wave of hatred that has swept the world." "It was known finally and forever that the Old World was dead, dead at the grief of the deep betrayal and dead of other things also, even partly dead of the plague which had finally become real." Yet "before the tide turned again" the Old World’s death became irrevocable.
The surviving children describe themselves as "onionized," with outer layers peeled away. Waking and sleep mingle, as do conscious and unconscious life. These changes accompany the new totemic order; the dispute over whether that order is real also puts their account of themselves at issue.
The plague killed the Old World along with its people. "When the Bottom fell out," reality quantum-jumped into a different type of world. The conflict is whether the new magian reality can hold or is, as the Prisoner claims, a subjective fiction.
The children elect Rufinus Lifshin as World Leader, but they divide over the Prisoner’s challenge to their new world. Rufinus lets him be heard; Venture helps free him. Governing means deciding which accounts of reality may be spoken and acted upon.
After a transmuted plague kills ninety-eight percent of humanity (leaving only children ten or younger alive), survivors from Captain Kusman's School form a new fetish-magic civilization. The Narrator on the Slippery Cloud observes as they elect a World Leader while responding to the Prisoner of Gridley Graves, who claims their New World is subjective fiction.
Sources for When All the World Was Young
R. A. Lafferty, When All the World Was Young. Transcription.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Onionization and mingled consciousness: p. 110.
- The Prisoner and the children’s divided responses: pp. 85–87, 89–90, 99, 124.
- The Old World’s death: pp. 129–130.
Oceanic Imagery
Not to Mention Camels
World-jumping and the inescapable Prime World
In the practice of "weighing a death," one measures the effect of a person's passing, such as that of the cult figure Pilger Tisman, instead of trying to preserve life. Certain "tricky individuals" can carry parts of themselves (memory or consciousness) beyond death by special means, leaving a "fast-spreading residue" that breeds "horrendous ghost worlds or counterworlds" able to interact physically with primary reality.
Pilgrim Dusmano, a major cult figure and "world-jumper," argues that the three prevailing world theories (worlds scattered across space, co-existing "alternate worlds," and a single world of "prime" and "shadow" souls) are "three aspects of the same thing," where "Out There" is also "In Here." He urges a deliberate "metacosmosis," a world-jumping by which one chooses the quality of one's later lives.
The Prime World threatens this aim. It is a world of rigid logic that he calls "the dullest of all possible worlds," without "buoyancy" and impossible to escape, and it is the one world in which a person who dies goes to Heaven or to Hell. Protected by Noah Zontik, Dusmano works his schemes through followers such as Mary and James Morey and through ritual violence, in a society dominated by Media Lords who stand for unreason and darkness.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Billions of parallel worlds exist simultaneously. "Prime World" is a singular, inescapable reality of absolute logic and consequence. The Nine Worlds of the Legacy exist outside of linear time as a state of being. "Out There" is also "In Here": the multiverse is internal as well as external.
The protagonist's identity shifts across worlds (the Pilgrim-figure: Tisman, Dusmano, Polder, etc.). Consciousness and memory are malleable, transferable substances. The self can be a "prime" original or a "derivative" projection or contrivance. The Media Lords have a schizo-gashed, artificial consciousness.
Pilgrim Dusmano creates and manipulates cults and commercial empires across worlds. Ritual death transforms people and carries them between worlds.
The Pilgrim-figure’s passage through worlds brings changes of name, body, and social power. The distinction between "prime" and "derivative" selves makes continuity a problem: it is unclear what persists through these transformations and what is copied or contrived.
World-jumping offers repeated escape from death and its consequences, while Prime World is the feared limit of that escape. Metacosmosis promises passage beyond a single world; the prospect of final judgment threatens further escape.
The Pilgrim-figure uses ritual death and world-jumping to renew his position, manipulating cults and commercial empires along the way. His repeated escapes sustain his power, but he fears Prime World, where death would allow no further jump.
A cult figure with a fractured identity (the Pilgrim-figure) jumps between parallel worlds upon his many ritualistic deaths. He fears being trapped in "Prime World," where world-jumping ends and death means Heaven or Hell.
Sources for Not to Mention Camels
R. A. Lafferty, Not to Mention Camels. Gollancz / SF Gateway eBook, 2016; copyright 1976.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Prime and the limit of escape: pp. 29–30, 237–239.
- Purchased influence in the Folk Ocean: pp. 164–166.
- Domdaniel’s archetypal company: pp. 179–180.
Oceanic Imagery
Apocalypses
Two novellas of world-ending and world-forging
The Apocalypses collection contains two novellas, Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis? and The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny. The first treats reality as forgery; the second treats fiction as world-creation. In both, manufactured realities (a physical illusion in one, prophetic fictions in the other) threaten to overwrite or destroy the world.
Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?
The para-material forgery and the Illusion of the Lavender Cloud
Constantine Quiche, the world's best detective, investigates the sudden, impossible appearance of the peninsula of Sandaliotis off the coast of Monaco. He must determine whether the new land is a miracle, a hoax, or something else. The case brings him among beautiful and deadly agents and shifting identities, and his own memory appears to have been tampered with.
He confronts a master forger, a murderous conspiracy, and the threat of a world-bomb in the sky. His investigation leads him from the shores of the new country to a thirteen-sided torture chamber, where his own identity and the nature of the case are called into question.
Themes
Reality is a "para-material" forgery. Sandaliotis is constructed from "air and water and salt, from the local atmosphere and the sea" through "gas plasmas," "swamp fires," and "oscillating oil slicks." The "Illusion of the Lavender Cloud" is "a sort of hypnotic cult device." Land appears where "ships and boats have sailed for ages," and deep fog becomes tolerably deep ocean.
Being is malleable and deceptive. Amelia Lilac appears in dolphin-human forms and is said to demonstrate bi-location. Constantine himself may be a forgery, struggling with gaps in his memory. The waters around the apparent islands are "concretions of our psychotic unconsciousnesses"; the unconscious lives in submarine caves. Creatures come from "the unconsciousnesses or the under-minds."
Change is apocalyptic collapse. The world-bomb hovers above while Sandaliotis threatens to dissolve, with people "falling screaming" to the ocean below the false land. Three great nations have sunk into the sea. The Fountains still leap but their pools are "all fallen and gone": churning, foaming shoal water, a maelstrom, a huge flow of water plunging down.
Sandaliotis casts doubt on both places and persons: the peninsula may be a construction, characters use simulacra, and Constantine’s memories may have been manipulated. His uncertainty about himself complicates his judgment of the country.
The threat is that the forged reality will collapse entirely, with people "falling screaming" to the ocean below the false land. The danger comes from the world-bomb overhead and from the dissolving peninsula; if the illusion fails, all that stands on it falls into the sea.
Constantine’s investigation threatens to expose the scheme, but he cannot securely separate his own role from its fabrications. The novella leaves open whether he has defeated the deception.
Detective Constantine Quiche, his identity and memory schizo-gashed, must determine the nature of Sandaliotis, a peninsula forged from fog and hypnosis, where people "walking on air, on colored air" may at any moment fall through "emptiness all the way down to the Sea."
Sources for Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?
R. A. Lafferty, Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?, in Apocalypses. Pinnacle, first printing October 1977.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Identity and memory under suspicion: pp. 70–71, 169.
- The national unconscious and submarine caves: p. 108.
- The construction and collapse of the land: pp. 148, 175–176, 190, 193–195.
The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny
The Crux-Individual whose fictions become apocalypse
A collection of documents recounts the life of Enniscorthy Sweeny, a kind man whose creative works, particularly his Armageddon Operas, seem to be bringing about the end of the world. Told through a collage of essays, letters, and an alternate twentieth-century chronology, the novella presents a world split between two realities: a peaceful "Golden Century" and an ongoing series of catastrophic wars.
Sweeny is identified as the "Crux-Individual" on whom reality depends. Friends and enemies, mathematicians and supernatural beings, pursue him; some want to kill him to keep his visions from coming true, and others protect him to ensure their fulfillment. The Devonian Equations predict the end of the world, and some believe that Sweeny's death is the only way to prevent it.
Reality is a manipulable narrative whose versions coexist. The world is simultaneously a peaceful "Golden Century" and a world being destroyed by the Armageddon Wars. Sweeny’s operas give artistic form to the catastrophic history that threatens to displace the peaceful account.
Sweeny is kind and apparently saintly, yet his art depicts horrors. Others interpret him as the source of catastrophe or make him a scapegoat for it. His responsibility for the horrors he imagines is uncertain.
The Devonian Equations identify Sweeny as a "Crux-Individual" and give some mathematicians a reason to seek his death. His Armageddon Operas depict catastrophic history. Mathematical prediction and artistic vision become grounds for action, while the equations themselves come under suspicion of manipulation.
The peaceful Golden Century and the Armageddon histories lead to incompatible readings of Sweeny’s art. A kind man is suspected of causing catastrophe; some try to save him, others to kill him.
Sweeny’s Armageddon Operas threaten the boundary between imagined catastrophe and actual history. The conflict concerns which account of the world will prevail and what will happen to the people within it. When war spreads at the close, the contest passes from stories into events.
Once the equations name Sweeny the "Crux-Individual," efforts to change history converge on his life. Some believe his death can prevent catastrophe; others protect him. He does not command all the forces acting through history.
Enniscorthy Sweeny, a kind man identified by a prophetic equation as the "Crux-Individual," must contend with his own creative visions, which threaten to become three literal Armageddons, while mathematicians who believe his death will save the world hunt him.
Sources for The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny
R. A. Lafferty, The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny, in Apocalypses. Pinnacle, first printing October 1977.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- The Crux-Individual and proposed assassination: pp. 240–241, 243.
- Competing histories and the disputed equations: pp. 305–308.
- The polluted pool: p. 366.
- The final Armageddon: pp. 383–384.
Dark Shine
World-creators expanding reality through Enabling Equations
Rolo N.B. Danovitz, Brendan Michaels, Beth Barabbas, Chróna Lorngold, Norbert Hardcore, Hornblende Michaelson, Nelly Mercury, and Felicity Octave arrive from the "Outer Winds Area" in a gusty manner, accompanied by building-rattling sound and the rich-ringing of coins and nuggets. Their sudden appearance is linked to the Earthquakes in May and the fabled "Earthquake Gold."
Identifying themselves as "world-creators" or "world-expanders," the group (officially the Spaciousness Unlimited Group or Rolo Group) aims at "making a world tomorrow" by replacing the old world with a new one, "Effecting of miracles of expansion and spaciousness, even to the making of new worlds, and turning it all at a profit."
Each has a particular function: Rolo, an eleven-year-old prodigy, is a "natural dictator" marked by "abysmal cruelty" and called the "present King of Babylon"; Brendan Michaels is the group's master mathematician and magician, devising "enabling equations" that bring new realities into being; Beth Barabbas is a former centurion and battle technician; Norbert Hardcore preserves the "Illusion of Spontaneity"; Chróna Lorngold (Rolo's genetically-tampered mother) is a "surpassing genius"; Nelly Mercury is expert in synthetic entities and the "illusion business"; and Felicity Octave is synthetic to the core. Their enterprise is constantly monitored by the Cocked Eye BAM (Benevolent Advisory Monitors), a sub-group of SNUFF, who capture transparencies of the group's dreams.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality exists in layers: "the real world underneath the artificial illusions," "a big balloon that we are all continually blowing up." Humanity is compared to an iceberg, with "only one eighth" visible; its leaders are described as only one-eighth awake. "Building has always gone on unconsciously"; its people are "welling up out of the earth," "oozing up with the fantastic ooze."
The group comprises world-creators, synthetic beings, and genetically-tampered geniuses. They operate largely unconsciously: "we did almost all of this in our sleep." Rolo is "unconscious of his own cruelty." Alongside them are the "Floating-World People": "they can emerge at any moment," "like quicksilver." In the No Dramas, painted eyes disguise unconscious creation: "That one is wide-awake. He is not in the unconscious, composing transport and ecstasy that we fear so much."
Change comes through catastrophic welling-up: "The Dam has burst; The Tide has Turned." "Volcanoes began to spit and spew," "rocks had melted, and they flowed like brooks," "Behemoths erupted out of the earth," "the dead rose, and issued out of their earth." The novel puts the question directly: "Have we been asleep or have we been mad?"
The world-creators work largely in their sleep, building more than they consciously know. They expand a world they cannot fully account for. Who is responsible for what their sleeping minds produce?
The Rolo Group aims at "making a world tomorrow" by replacing the old one entirely. Their enabling equations bring new realities into being. When the dam bursts and the tide turns, the old world gives way to catastrophic expansion from beneath.
The eight figures (the dictator-child Rolo, the mathematician Brendan, the synthetic Felicity, and the others) bring about the transformation through their unconscious building. Their "enabling equations" and dream-work produce the new world, and the Cocked Eye BAM monitors the dreams in which it is made.
A group of eight world-creators, including an eleven-year-old dictator, a master mathematician of "enabling equations," and synthetic beings, expand reality through unconscious building, watched by the Cocked Eye BAM, as "the tide has turned" and the old world gives way to catastrophic transformation.
Sources for Dark Shine
R. A. Lafferty, Dark Shine. Transcription.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Enabling equations: pp. 20–21.
- Unconscious building and awareness: pp. 35, 37, 41, 51.
- Surveillance of the Group’s dreams: pp. 46–47.
Oceanic Imagery
The Elliptical Grave
Devolution, time excavation, and the cocoon-grave voyage
Professor Pioneer J. Reventlo has a radical theory: mankind has devolved from a state of immense primordial complexity instead of evolving from simplicity. To prove this, he and a team of academics, students, and quasi-mythological beings launch an expedition to the "White Goat Valley" in Calabria, Italy, a place that is a time machine and a center of illusion.
They undertake a metaphysical excavation of the earth, the "haunted air," and the "mind-sphere," which goes well beyond an archaeological dig. As they uncover evidence of a lost golden age, supernatural enemies hound them, and the reality around them grows unstable.
The expedition ends with the group trapped in a pavilion that passes into temporal stasis, a cosmic cocoon in which they must face the true, terrifying shape of the universe and await their own mutational jump. The pavilion becomes "a coffin, a grave, a cocoon (which is a bomb), an ark, a pavilion, a world" and "the ark and the grave and the whale and the pavilion," and in it they set out on a voyage in an elliptical grave.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality is an "uncharted ocean" where time is a physical and fluid entity. White Goat Valley is a time machine and a center of illusion. The expedition conducts "time-excavations," raiding the unconscious and the "caverns of the folk unconscious." "The unconscious is always a sea"; reality is a "fluid sea-medium" of "under-seas dreams."
In Reventlo's theory, humanity has devolved from immense primordial complexity; human beings are diminished and have lost a golden age. The expedition members are creatures in cocoons traveling on a voyage, becoming "sea-changed," experiencing "a sort of 'sea change' in the unconscious." They are "fish drowning in the air," "tadpole in the cocoon."
Change comes through entrapment and transformation: the group is trapped in a pavilion that becomes "a coffin, a grave, a cocoon (which is a bomb), an ark": cocoons made out of water, with walls and lids of water. They are "buried alive" in "Life In the Grave" awaiting "Death By Drowning" or mutational rebirth. It is "Three Days In The Belly Of A Fish," a voyage in an elliptical grave.
Reventlo reads humanity as diminished from primordial complexity. The expedition’s confinement challenges that account: Jeffery Wind eventually describes the archetypes as projections from the future. On his account, the forms the expedition has been excavating belong to the future.
The expedition excavates time and the mind-sphere in pursuit of Reventlo’s account of devolution. Confined in the pavilion-cocoon, the investigators must find a way through the transformation they had intended to explain.
Reventlo and his team become participants in the process they came to study. Their sea-change in the unconscious and burial in the elliptical grave make transformation a question of survival. Their explanations compete while the possibility of escape takes form within the group.
Professor Reventlo's expedition to prove humanity devolved from primordial complexity leads them into White Goat Valley, a time machine and center of illusion, where they become trapped in a pavilion that transforms into a cocoon-grave: "the ark and the grave and the whale and the pavilion," awaiting mutation or dissolution.
Sources for The Elliptical Grave
R. A. Lafferty, The Elliptical Grave. Typeset reading copy; imprint not stated.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Reventlo’s theory of devolution: pp. 4–5.
- Confinement, the unconscious sea, and mutation: pp. 80–83, 85.
- Jeffery Wind’s reversal of the theory: p. 86.
Oceanic Imagery
Fair Hills of Ocean, Oh!
The Boat People arrive as conquerors while Domdaniel stirs beneath
The novel opens with the arrival of the "Boat People" at every port in the world. Their hundreds of green-gray-blue boats, apparently alive and without visible power, appear suddenly along the docks. The Boat People are robust and ruddy, with carrot-orange or red hair and buckskin-colored skin, and they declare themselves "conquerors and occupiers" rather than refugees.
Though armed only with daggers, short swords, and spears, they show powers such as walking on water, skiing across the surface on cockle shells, and speaking local languages fluently. They take over governments quickly and behave inconsistently: they pay in ancient gold coins, yet they are ruthless when ignored (in Calcutta they slaughtered those who disregarded them). They have throat gills and can breathe underwater.
Meanwhile, the Matamoros Chapter of the Informal Committee for Advising Directors of Corporations and Nations, a secret society, assembles at Emmet Briny's Dunes of Hell resort. Their session is interrupted by Robert Al-dolphin Liffy, a super-intelligent bottlenose dolphin, double agent, and would-be "Emperor of Domdaniel." Robert dismisses the arrivals as a cyclical "swarming" recurring every few centuries, hinting that the real answers lie with the "smart dealers" of Domdaniel Fortress.
Five members (Oscar Judgement, Esther Scarlet, Carol Medusa, Jorge Medusa, and Margret Kirkestol) undertake a balloon voyage to Domdaniel with Robert as guide. They arrive at an underwater stronghold where captured world leaders are imprisoned, ruled by the Emperor Carmody Overlark. There the group is confined to Domdaniel's dreaded "Masterpieces of Death Room."
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality is layered: "the ocean bottoms are the plains and low lands; the mountains are the high waters." A whole civilization exists beneath: "the ocean depths, the underwater world, all was opened up to them." The surface world is the visible part; "the life-flow that was older than dry land" pulses below, and "the oceanic pulse of the entire world" governs events.
The Boat People have throat gills and walk on water; there is "something fishy about them." Robert Al-dolphin Liffy is "a double agent out of the ocean," a super-intelligent dolphin speaking through a translator. Being is fluid: "the ocean is full of such metamorphies." The visitors acquire "a taste of ocean-dream-thought" and "the oceanic element added to their thoughts."
Change comes through periodic irruption: Robert dismisses the invasion as "swarming" that recurs every few centuries. Deeper change is brewing in Domdaniel, the underwater fortress imprisoning world leaders. "The tide will turn." "The hills of Ocean skip like lambs": the whole oceanic order is in motion, "swimming in purgatorial waters."
The Boat People’s gills and Robert’s dolphin body give them capacities the land visitors lack. Synthetic throat-gills open the depths to the committee; altered perception brings "a taste of ocean-dream-thought." Underwater, the visitors acquire new abilities and perceive their surroundings differently.
Robert describes the Boat People’s arrival as recurring swarming, while Domdaniel holds captured world leaders beneath the sea. The committee’s investigation moves from an apparent invasion toward the hidden government of the world and the intentions of its emperor.
Robert Al-dolphin Liffy (super-intelligent dolphin, double agent, and would-be Emperor of Domdaniel) moves between the worlds and sets the action going. By guiding the committee to the underwater fortress, he brings on the confrontation.
Amphibious "Boat People" appear worldwide as conquerors, displaying powers like walking on water and breathing through throat gills, while a secret committee learns from a dolphin double agent that the real threat lies in Domdaniel Fortress, the underwater empire where captured world leaders are imprisoned in the "Masterpieces of Death Room."
Sources for Fair Hills of Ocean, Oh!
R. A. Lafferty, Fair Hills of Ocean, Oh!. Transcription.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Robert’s double agency and the committee’s journey: pp. 25–26, 35, 40–42.
- Oceanic thought and synthetic throat-gills: pp. 62, 65–66.
- Domdaniel and the captive leaders: pp. 49, 54, 121.
Oceanic Imagery
Aurelia
The Shining World girl governing a minor world while confronting her Dark Counterpart
Fourteen-year-old Aurelia comes from the Shining World, where fourteen-year-olds are assigned to govern minor worlds as part of a World Government school program. Weak in both starship design and navigation, Aurelia forgot to create key components like a Monitory Chronometer and a Compensating Contingency Grid, leaving her landing site to chance.
She arrives on an unfamiliar world, where her natural abilities appear miraculous to the inhabitants; some hail her as the Messiah, others fear her as the Devil, and she herself has trouble identifying the planet. Awkward and deficient by comparison with her peers, Aurelia undertakes the mission, which is regarded as both a "purging" and a "romantic episode" that transforms the "Shining People" into adults.
A "Dark Counterpart" lands at the same time. Aurelia must contend with the inhabitants’ reactions and the burdens of governing while facing her shadow double. She travels among the people of the "floating world," who live on River Boats and in swamps and lakes, and who speak to fish.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality is a "floating world" of uncertain status. Aurelia arrives by chance, unable even to identify where she is. The lines between life and death have been eroded. Its mathematics has "invisible depths" and "a few unexpected sea-serpents in those depths," though "it's mostly murk there." Information "simply slipped away."
Aurelia is one of the "Shining People" undergoing transformation, but she is awkward and deficient. Her authority is challenged by her "Dark Counterpart," who claims a governing role of his own. The inhabitants include "people of the 'floating world'" who "live on the indestructible fish," "trolls who live under the bridges," beings who maintain "one foot in the floating world."
Change is a "purging of yourselves," of "traits to be jettisoned" that "fall through the sieve." The mission transforms the Shining People into adults through trial. "Blind destruction rises up and gobbles one up." Change comes through confrontation with the Dark Counterpart, through "creatures still being born out of the slime."
Aurelia arrives with a governing mission and an adversarial counterpart whose role she does not understand. People of the "floating world" offer unfamiliar forms of belonging, while others greet her as a promised ruler. Her identity as one of the Shining People gives her powers without ensuring that she understands those around her.
Aurelia’s assignment is to govern an unfamiliar world according to the expectations of the Shining People. The floating world resists her, and its uncertain reality threatens to absorb her.
Aurelia must learn to govern as she grows into adulthood. Cousin Clootie, identified as her Dark Counterpart, claims that figures like him do the meaningful governing behind the Shining People’s bright distraction. She must govern while another claimant says he is already doing the work.
Aurelia, a deficient Shining World teenager assigned to govern an unknown planet, must find her way in a "floating world" where she is seen as Messiah or Devil, while confronting her Dark Counterpart in a trial that will either transform her into an adult or destroy her.
Sources for Aurelia
R. A. Lafferty, Aurelia. Scan.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- The Shining People’s trial and governing mission: pp. 8–10, 15–18.
- The floating world: pp. 38–41.
- The counterpart’s arrival and claim to govern: pp. 22–23, 104, 118.
Oceanic Imagery
Sindbad: The 13th Voyage
Master Mariner Essindibad and the search for the Boy-Caliph on Hell Planet
A fantasy-adventure novel that gathers the accounts of several "lesser persons" into a "Master Narration": a long, self-referential yarn about identity, reality, and good and evil.
The central quest begins when Essindibad Copperbottom, a Master Mariner and Spy from the "Melody World" of Kentauron Mikron, marked by a "Sea-Weed" growth, is sent with his wife, the Grand-Dame Tumblehome, to find Harun Al-Rashid, the Boy-Caliph, who is rumored to have been "born again" on Gaea-Earth. This primitive world, also known as "Pandora World" or "Hell Planet," is where the "Ultimate Evil" once escaped and is home to Baghdad Mirage, "The Last City Built By Magic," a place of wonders and anachronisms.
The identity of the hero is contested by John Scarlatti Thunderson, a "simple kid" from Chicago who invented an "Almost-Anything Space-and-Time Ship" using "Open-Ended Analytics" and proclaims himself the "real Sindbad," supported by his wife Azraq-Qamar, a former mechanical effigy brought to life. Other characters include Scheherazade Carrillo y Krynski, a "Master Story-Teller" from a future century; Harun's older-looking sons Mamun the Great and Al-Amin; Master Spies from the "Five Worlds" (Astrobe, Camiroi, Dahae, Kentauron Mikron, Gaea-Earth); and Magi Badadilma the Armenian, the "Last Magi" who authenticates "Golden Boys" and lives in Noah's Ark.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality spans the "Five Worlds" (Astrobe, Camiroi, Dahae, Kentauron Mikron, Gaea-Earth). Gaea-Earth is "Hell Planet" where "Ultimate Evil" escaped, home to "Baghdad Mirage, The Last City Built By Magic." Below the surface, "the oceanic under-minds of all of us are permeated by the spirits," and there are "submarine channels right to those infernal doors."
Sindbad’s identity is marked by the "Sea-Weed growth." The Boy-Caliph Harun Al-Rashid is a "Golden Boy" with "unhuman" nature and "actuality of evil." John Scarlatti Thunderson claims to be the "real Sindbad." Azraq-Qamar is a former mechanical effigy brought to life by a spirit.
Change comes through the quest: "perpetually bouncing on a sea of uneasiness," "instructions in my under-mind had been welling up into my consciousness." The search leads through low dives in the cellars and cisterns and sewers; sub-cellars and the sub-sewers; great depths and even blue skies below one.
Across the Five Worlds, embodied identity can conceal another agency: a mechanical effigy can receive a spirit, and John Thunderson can claim to be the "real Sindbad." The oceanic under-mind complicates the question of who speaks and acts within a person.
The search for the reborn Boy-Caliph takes Essindibad to Gaea-Earth, where Ultimate Evil has escaped. Baghdad Mirage and the voyage through hidden depths connect the search for a person with the problem of evil at work in the world.
John Thunderson’s claim to be the "real Sindbad" challenges Essindibad’s understanding of his role. Instructions well up from the Master Mariner’s under-mind as the quest proceeds. He must decide which inward promptings and rival claims to trust.
Master Mariner Essindibad Copperbottom (marked by Sea-Weed growth) must find the reborn Boy-Caliph Harun Al-Rashid on Gaea-Earth/"Hell Planet" while rival claims to be the real Sindbad multiply. The quest leads through Baghdad Mirage and through the oceanic under-minds, which are permeated by spirits.
Sources for Sindbad, the Thirteenth Voyage
R. A. Lafferty, Sindbad, the Thirteenth Voyage. Gollancz / SF Gateway eBook, 2016.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Rival claims to Sindbad’s identity: pp. 6–7, 72.
- The search for the Boy-Caliph: pp. 24, 30–31.
- The mechanical effigy and the oceanic under-minds: pp. 71–72, 81, 87.
Oceanic Imagery
Annals of Klepsis
The Pirate Planet, the Doomsday Equation, and the dreaming brain that contains the universe
The novel is set in an unstable closed system: a kinetic three-dimensional ellipse of four suns and seventeen habitable worlds, all under threat from the "Doomsday Equation," which dictates that the system must follow its tertiary focus into extinction. This focus is both a point and a person on the planet Klepsis (the Thief or Pirate Planet), identified by the code name the "Horseshoe Nail": a figure more than two hundred years old who is Quasimodo, the "sleeper" in Ravel-Brannagan Castle. The balance of the cosmos depends on one condition: the Horseshoe Nail must not be allowed to wake, and he must not be allowed to die.
The narrator, Long John Tong Tyrone, is a historian who journeys to Klepsis seeking history, joined by fellow peg-legs traveling under a fund for one-legged Irishmen established by the planet's founder, Christopher Brannagan. Tyrone's companions include Terpsichore Callagy (seeking art whose colors "bark and howl out loud at you"), Andrew "Gold Coast" O'Mally (seeking gold with over a hundred treasure maps), and Conchita O'Brian (seeking coded technology, though Tyrone suspects this is a code for something else).
Klepsis is officially a "Covenanted Piracy" with no towns. It has the only freshwater ocean known on the seventeen habitable worlds, to which visitors must add salt, and perpetually bright landscapes of brilliantly colored vegetation. Customs include the use of highly hallucinatory "My God What Grapes!" grapes, swift and brutal executions (playing sudden-death poker for who lives or hangs), and moneylenders who implant explosive slivers in debtors' skulls to guarantee repayment within about twelve days. Newspapers print on self-destructing paper to prevent the world from being choked by it, contributing to the idea that the world "has no history."
The center of intrigue is Ravel-Brannagan Castle, which "contains all the history that there is on Klepsis." Occupants include the Ghost of Christopher Brannagan (the founder, a peg-legged specter who worries about the world having no history), Prince Henry the Pirate (the present cruel ruler), his twin Prince Franco the Outcast (who is "more pleasant" and can "go vague" and vanish from his clothes), Princess Angela Gilmartin Ravel (famed as the most beautiful woman on Klepsis), and Tharrala Thorn (a Princess in disrepute for an "unspeakable sin"). Tyrone and his companions move through a world whose reality is in question: the universe may be only "imaginings" in a single mind, perhaps Brannagan's or Quasimodo's, and that possibility bears on the mystery of the Doomsday Equation.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality may be the imagination of a sleeping mind. The universe is "an unstable closed system," possibly the dream of Quasimodo or Brannagan, who holds all of us in his brain now. Characters wonder "how can we hide from a person in his own brain?" The world has no history because newspapers self-destruct; the Castle "contains all the history that there is." Klepsis has the only freshwater ocean known on the seventeen habitable worlds.
Identity is fractured and doubled: Prince Franco can "go vague" and vanish from his clothes, "a sort of ghostliness about a twin." The Ghost of Brannagan may be the perhaps-ghost, "my own person and ghost." Characters may be "imaginary nonbeings" in another's dream. The protagonists are all one-legged.
The Doomsday account makes the Horseshoe Nail, Quasimodo, the focus on which the universe depends: he must neither wake nor die. Quasimodo reports this riddle but questions its premise. The threatened catastrophe makes preserving his condition urgent without settling whether all persons exist only in his mind.
Ghosts, vanishing twins, and the possibility of "imaginary nonbeings" make the boundaries of personhood uncertain. The voyage takes Tyrone and his companions into a landscape identified as Brannagan’s brain. Quasimodo, however, questions whether containing everyone in a mind makes them only imaginings.
According to the Doomsday account, either waking or death would destroy the universe dependent on the Horseshoe Nail. Quasimodo asks how the Doomsday people know this. The danger lies in acting on an explanation whose implications are catastrophic and whose basis is in dispute.
Tyrone’s pursuit of history leads him to the sleeper on whom the Doomsday account makes the universe depend. His investigation puts suppressed records and claims about cosmic survival together. In seeking the truth, he must also judge the danger said to lie in discovering it.
On Klepsis, the Pirate Planet with no history and a freshwater ocean, one-legged historian Long John Tong Tyrone seeks the truth of a universe that may exist only in a sleeper's dream, while the Doomsday Equation threatens extinction if the Horseshoe Nail (Quasimodo in his two-hundred-year sleep) either wakes or dies.
Sources for Annals of Klepsis
R. A. Lafferty, Annals of Klepsis. Ace Original, August 1983.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- The voyage into Brannagan’s brain: pp. 159–160.
- Quasimodo’s account of the riddle and his objection: pp. 179–180.
Oceanic Imagery
East of Laughter
The Group of Twelve and the one-hundred-and-one dream trials
The novel centers on The Group of Twelve, individuals chosen to provide "extraordinary and onerous service to the world," who repeatedly ask whether their reality is genuine, testing it against the "one-hundred-and-one" dream trials created by the ancient Roman Scribbling Giant Atrox Fabulinus. Atrox has been dead for more than fifteen hundred years, yet his work inexplicably continues to receive new chapters, which strengthens the suspicion that their world is a dream.
This world rests on the Twenty-One Pillars (Seven Saints, Seven Technicians, and Seven Scribbling Giants), and the Giants prove nearly irreplaceable during the "Changing of the Aeons."
The group's members include Hilary Ardri, a Computerized Fish Tycoon whose machine draws fish from empty waters; Jane Chantal Ardri, a fuzzy huntress with a hunting horn housing her invisible female computer Joyeuse Vice-Reine; Solomon Izzersted and John Barkley Towntower, who share one body (Solomon, the grotesque growth on John's belly, is secretly superior); Laughter-Lynn Casement, who remembers emerging from a goose egg sixteen years after her first birth; Leo Parisi, a nuclear scientist disillusioned by atoms as "empty boxes"; Perpetua Parisi, using "Behaviouristic Logic" to forecast events; Gorgonius Pantera, a piano-maker who has lived in three centuries; Caesar Oceano, a shipping magnate partnered with Prince Leonardo the Great, a golden panther from the "Exterior Darkness"; Denis Lollardy, the world's greatest forger; Mary Brandy Manx, mayor of Port Saint Mary with her "brandy voice"; and Hieronymous Talking-Crow, who claims humans live in a "larvae-state."
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality may be a dream: "Are We Dreaming?" The world is an unreal world ambient tested by the hundred-and-one dream trials of the long-dead Scribbling Giant Atrox Fabulinus, whose work inexplicably continues receiving new chapters. The Twelve are "chin-deep in the waters of survival."
Being is multiple and impossible: two men share one body (Solomon growing from John's belly), a woman emerged from a goose egg sixteen years after her first birth, a piano-maker has lived in three centuries, a golden panther speaks with insight. Caesar Oceano is the "Price-Cut-Throat of the Seven Seas." They may be characters in another's dream.
The "Changing of the Aeons" requires renewal of the Twenty-One Pillars: Seven Saints, Seven Technicians, and Seven Scribbling Giants. Daniel Delany casts the danger in oceanic terms: "We must find New Giants, or we must drown."
Two men share one body, Laughter-Lynn has emerged from a goose egg, and a golden panther speaks with insight. The Group of Twelve has personal reasons to question ordinary accounts of reality. Their extraordinary capacities also equip them for the service demanded by the changing aeon.
The death of a Pillar makes the world stagger until a replacement is found. The Changing of the Aeons therefore requires succession as well as invention. The mystery of Atrox Fabulinus’s continuing work sharpens the question of who can take up the burden of sustaining the world.
The Group of Twelve is chosen for "extraordinary and onerous service." They put their capacities to work: Gorgonius and Denis accept work as Scribbling Giants, while Monika uses her wish to seek replacement of the missing Pillar.
The Group of Twelve, including a fish tycoon, a piano-maker who has lived in three centuries, and a golden panther, must determine whether their reality is genuine or a dream, tested by the hundred-and-one trials of a dead Scribbling Giant whose work mysteriously continues, during the "Changing of the Aeons."
Sources for East of Laughter
R. A. Lafferty, East of Laughter. Morrigan Publications, 1988.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- Domdaniel and the Ocean’s governors: p. 94.
- New Giants as an alternative to drowning: p. 125.
- The Pillars, succession, and service: pp. 165, 174.
Oceanic Imagery
Serpent's Egg
The Magic Dozen and Inneall's Ocean in the Floating World
The novel is set in the "Global Village" of 2035, a "Floating World" governed by the nearly invisible Kangaroo, an elitist interspecies authority that orders assassinations for the common good. Through hybrid killers called the Dolophonoi, it eliminates dangerous "Serpent's Egg" experiments, those that succeed "only too well."
The novel centers on the Lynn-Randal Experiment, which raised together three "super-mega-persons": Lord Randal, an "enhanced" human boy with an off-the-scale IQ; Axel, a gargoyle-faced Axel's Ape whose father founded an underground ape society; and Inneall, an Ambulatory Mime-Human Computer who insists she is the little girl "Bloody Mary Muldoon the Pirate Queen." Inneall created a vast, ever-expanding Ocean.
They later join children from three other experiments to form the Magic Dozen: Marino (a young male seal), Luas (a young male angel), Henryetta (a fiery human girl), Lutin (a prophetic pythoness), Dubu (a young female bear), Schimp (a young male chimpanzee), Gajah (an unborn "Wonder of the World Elephant"), Carcajou (a wolverine of "evil intelligence"), and Popugai (a young male parrot). Guided by the wealthy surrogate grandfather Satrap Saint Ledger, the Dozen gather at Heart's Desire Cove on the shore of their Ocean, aware that as they near their tenth birthdays, the Kangaroo may judge them a Serpent's Egg. The story builds toward "The Three Days of Summerset," a time of foreboding.
Themes
A-B-C Diagnostic
Reality is a "Floating World": "The Floating World was a giant boat or ark"; any heavier-than-water boat can sink if it ships enough water. Inneall created a vast, ever-expanding Ocean, "extents of water that are standing where no water stood yesterday." In its depths is "the Castle named Domdaniel which is at the bottom of the Ocean."
Being is hybrid and experimental: Lord Randal (enhanced human), Axel (Axel's Ape), Inneall (Ambulatory Computer who made the Ocean), Marino (seal), Luas (angel), Lutin (pythoness), Dubu (bear), Schimp (chimpanzee), Gajah (unborn elephant), Carcajou (evil wolverine). "All of the underwater creatures live in an active state of churning unconsciousness"; "All of them live in dreamworlds."
Change comes as threat: the Kangaroo eliminates "Serpent's Egg" experiments through the Dolophonoi. As the Dozen approach their tenth birthdays, they may be judged dangerous. The Ocean Metastasis is "a dream state of incomparable vividness," "the Oceanic Hyper-Active Dream State." The novel invokes the day "When the Sea Shall Give Up Its Dead."
The Magic Dozen come from four experiments that bring different forms of life and intelligence together. They explore Inneall’s new ocean. Through the Ocean Metastasis, they enter its depths in a vivid dream state.
Inneall created an Ocean that keeps expanding, swallowing roads and valleys. Her experiment alters the world, making water stand where none stood before. Such powers expose the children to the Kangaroo’s judgment that an experiment may succeed "only too well."
The twelve hybrid children gather at the shore of their own Ocean as their tenth birthdays approach. The Kangaroo may judge them a Serpent's Egg, which could hatch into a new world or be eliminated first by the Dolophonoi. The story builds toward the Three Days of Summerset.
In the "Floating World" of 2035, the Magic Dozen, children from four experiments, face judgment from the Kangaroo authority as a "Serpent's Egg" that succeeds "only too well," while gathering at Heart's Desire Cove on the shore of Inneall's ever-expanding Ocean for "The Three Days of Summerset."
Sources for Serpent's Egg
R. A. Lafferty, Serpent's Egg. Morrigan Publications, 1987.
References below use PDF page numbers in the consulted copy.
- The four experiments and the growing Ocean: pp. 30, 58, 65–66.
- The Ocean Metastasis: p. 143.
Oceanic Imagery
Cross-Novel Synthesis
Themes shared across the oceanic novels
The Domdaniel Thread
Domdaniel locates hidden powers beneath the sea. In Camels it houses an archetypal company; in East of Laughter it is the meeting place of the Ocean’s governors; in Fair Hills it belongs to an underwater political order. The castle conceals different kinds of authority: archetypal, economic, and political.
The Polluted Pool
In Sweeny, Widdershins describes collective consciousness as an oil-slick surface above depths haunted by the wars. Camels makes the shared ocean a medium open to purchased influence, while Sandaliotis places a national unconscious in submarine caves. Their depths hold different forms of concealed pressure: historical catastrophe, manipulation, and collective fear.
The Narrative Sea
Narrative enters these worlds in distinct ways. Space Chantey gives a voyage epic form; East of Laughter and Iron Tongue make the writing of scenarios part of the world’s operation; Sweeny sets rival histories against one another. Klepsis makes access to history a problem. An ocean voyage can carry characters through an epic, into a mind, or toward the powers that write their world.
Crossings and Their Limits
Camels makes Prime World the feared end of world-jumping and evasion of judgment. Sandaliotis tests the apparent solidity of a country; Sindbad carries its quest among worlds and into hidden depths; Fair Hills opens a submerged civilization to land visitors. Pilgrim seeks passage out of judgment; the Fair Hills visitors enter the depths to discover who governs their world.
The Schizo-Gash
Divided being takes different forms: rival psychic powers in Fourth Mansions, programmed control in Past Master, alien belonging in The Reefs of Earth, and composite personhood in Easterwine. Each novel asks how a person can act with integrity under these pressures.
The Hatching
Transformation often takes the form of emergence from eggs, cocoons, and hidden depths. Serpent’s Egg places experimental lives under threat before maturity; The Elliptical Grave confines its investigators in a pavilion that is also grave, ark, and cocoon. Fourth Mansions makes mutation a contested passage, while Fair Hills brings the submerged world into contact with the surface.